1 week ago Wednesday, I (25M) matched with this girl (23F) on Hinge. After matching, we texted nonstop for nearly 8 hours each day for two days straight. I know that sounds crazy, but the conversations were amazing, with no dry moments or awkward pauses. They were genuinely fluid. We talked about each other’s interests, goals, reasons for being on the app, our backgrounds, etc.—things that I would usually skim over and discuss further on a first date. To me, it was clear that we should meet up to see if we had that chemistry in person, so I asked her if she was free on Saturday. She responded, “Yes.”
Saturday – The First Date:
Saturday came, and I planned to take her to a nice coffee shop connected to a mall. It was my idea so she could feel a sense of safety. However, we ended up walking around the mall for about 8 hours without ever going to the coffee shop because we were so distracted and deep into conversation. I’ve never felt such a strong connection with a potential partner before. At no point did anything feel forced from either of us—time just flew by, and we were both surprised by how quickly it passed (which seemed like a good sign).
At one point, she asked if I was talking to anyone else. I said “No” (which was true), and she then showed me her phone, which had over 400 matches from just 2 days on Hinge. She had only texted one other person, but she openly admitted she wasn’t interested in them and was interested in me.
The Conversation:
Some things she brought up on the first date were deeper than I’d usually get into so early on—insecurities, sexual experiences, deep family issues, and even how many kids I wanted. She asked if I would be okay if she got an IUD (in hindsight, that was probably a red flag to bring up on a first date). She also joked about things like whose last name the kids would take. It was all a bit overwhelming, but I just went with the flow.
When we got onto the topic of exes, she mentioned her last partner. She said that he played her by admitting, “I got what I wanted,” and that she wasn’t sure if she was fully over him. She also mentioned that she still follows him on social media but doesn’t believe in blocking exes. I’m the same way, but I don’t think I would still follow my exes. I took it as a red flag, but didn’t say anything, just kept going with the conversation.
End of the Night:
Later, we ended up going to a steakhouse because it was the only place open at 11 PM nearby, and I had a good feeling about the night, so I didn’t mind. After dinner (yes, I paid), we went back to my car, and I surprised her with flowers. She almost teared up and said no guy had ever given her flowers. I kissed her on the cheek, but I didn’t want to make her feel uncomfortable or forced.
We then sat in the car and started talking about the second date. I told her I wanted to surprise her, and she seemed excited. She even said she couldn’t wait to tell her friends about me and asked if I’d tell my family. I thought that was a bit too forward and definitely way too soon, but in the moment, I was “love-blinded” and felt like she was “the one,” so I told her, “Yes.”
At the end of the night, we shared a long hug, locked eyes, and I asked if it would be okay to give her a kiss. She said she would prefer to wait until the second date, and I completely respected that. She asked me to text her when I got home (it was 4 AM by this point). She felt bad about the late hour and said she’d invite me upstairs but that her place was a mess. I told her it was fine and texted her when I got home to let her know I made it back safely.
The Day After:
The next morning, I texted her “Good morning,” which she told me was cute, but I noticed her response times started slowing down. She was leaving me on read for hours at a time, so I took the hint and gave her some space. I had a feeling something was off, and while I tend to overthink, I’m usually not wrong when I do.
In the afternoon, I was surprised to receive a massive message—over 800 words. She said she didn’t want to lead me on because she didn’t feel the “attraction.” She told me I was the nicest guy, that she liked me, but wasn’t sure if it could become a relationship. She said she would be willing to go on another date, but she couldn’t guarantee that it would turn into anything serious. She wanted us to see other people while we worked on the “attraction” as friends. She reassured me it wasn’t anything I did or how I looked.
Her Message and My Response:
Reading her message was tough. I took about an hour to respond, thanking her for her honesty and telling her I must have picked up the wrong signals. I explained that I have never befriended someone I have romantic feelings for, and that I’m not the type of person who dates multiple people at once. I stuck to my values and made it clear that I wasn’t interested in just being friends.
She responded with another long message saying she really wanted to make it work and suggested that we take some time to be friends and see if the attraction could grow. She told me I could take my time to figure it out and let her know when I was ready.
The Christmas Day Message:
Two days after her paragraph, on Christmas Day, I posted a picture of myself at the gym with a “Happy Holidays” caption. She messaged me saying, “You don’t need to be going to the gym for me. Your physical appearance had nothing to do with it. I think you’re cute, but the attraction is missing.” I found this a bit odd and told her that I wasn’t going to the gym for her. This experience had just sparked a desire in me to work on my confidence, and I had been meaning to go to the gym. It wasn’t for her, but she did give me the push to start.
Where I Stand Now:
It’s been 5 days since our last communication, and I’m still really confused about what to do next. In the past, if I’ve ever been friend-zoned, I would just move on. But in this case, I wanted to come here for advice.
People around me are telling me to cut things off completely. Others are saying to be friends with her and see if the attraction grows over time, and some suggest not to pursue a relationship but to just be friends. I do really like her—or maybe it’s the idea of her. I want to see where this could go, but I also know I’m not the type of guy who can be friends with someone I have romantic feelings for, especially if she starts dating someone else in the future.
The conversation ended with her agreeing to wait to hear from me about whether I’m ready to be friends.
Looking for Advice:
I’m really stuck on what to do. Should I try to be friends and see if the attraction grows, or should I move on? I’m not sure I can handle being just friends, especially if she ends up dating someone else in a few months.
Any advice would be really appreciated!
Thanks for reading through all of this, and sorry for the long post. I just wanted to give enough context to get some solid advice.