r/OnePiece Sep 07 '24

Discussion Saturn is one of the most well-written hypocritical frauds I've seen in a while. Spoiler

Despite proclaiming that he is a god, This guy just proves that he is a human every time he appears on screen.

He is so insecure and he needs so bad to prove that he is superior to others, even someone who is a slave like Kuma. Which is contrasted by the other gorousei who are pretty self-confident and don't need to prove anything. He fits the theme of Human contradiction so well, which is the main theme of the arc.

Everything he does gets back at him, He experimented on Ginny but ended up making a mini nika, He ordered the wiping of Kuma's personality but he was still able to protect bonney with willpower alone, and finally he allowed luffy to escape by refusing to destroy Emet.

It is ironic. in Kuma's flashback, He told him that he can't understand why humans always try to do what they are told not to do, But he ends up dying because of disobeying orders and refusing to destroy the robot. It was because of his human need to prove himself that he disobeyed orders just like the people he consider insects. It is poetic.

He is a horrible person but an amazing character. I love him so much.

RIP my fraud king.

735 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

-11

u/Open_Inspector_7863 Sep 07 '24

The most one dimensional villain in 15 years doesnt suddenly become a well written character just because his constant and everlasting failures open up a brief parallel between his longing of self realization and the fact that he is regularly putting everyone down for the same behaviour. We know nothing about him. Him barely being a human and therefore becoming ridiculously uninteresting is the result of the route oda wanted to go with him. I can just hope this wont be the main theme for the rest of the final antagonists.

8

u/sami_newgate Sep 07 '24

He is definitely a three dimensional antagonist.

The main theme of egghead is human contradiction. Being a god with inferiority complex makes him the perfect antagonist for this arc.

We know almost everything about him. The beauty of his character is that the more he rejects his humanity, the more he proves that he is just a human.

Saying that he is barely a human is just a proof that you didn’t understand his character.

He is a human more than anyone else, just like kuma and bonney. His hypocrisy and need of proving himself is a proof of that.

You need to read more stories if you think that we need flashbacks to understand characters.

-9

u/Open_Inspector_7863 Sep 07 '24

I never said we need flashbacks for understanding characters or for them to be interesting, you are assuming a whole lot here. Me saying he is barely human is intentional because he is. He is not "more human than anyone else". Saturn just has one bad human trait turned up to a thousand and you are spinning all of your enjoyment out of this one aspect, which is fine. It still doesnt make him enjoyable, intruiging or interesting to me. He is playing in the same sandbox as Hody Jones. Thematically relevant but completely dull and uninteresting as a character.

10

u/sami_newgate Sep 07 '24

That’s what your words indicated. It seems that you are not capable of understanding characterization outside of backstories.

His inferiority complex definitely makes him intriguing and thought provoking. It is just that you are not trying to think. So you can’t comprehend why it is so deep.

Hody is amazing. But saturn is way better. Saturn is a fully fleshed-out human being while what’s interesting about hody is the way he came to existence.

Saturn is definitely more human than anyone else. In an arc about human contradiction. Him, Vp and kizaru are the perfect side characters to explore this theme.

He is interesting for anyone who is looking for deep writing. If a self-proclaimed god with inferiority complex doesn’t interest you then I don’t know what does lmao.

He is an s-tier antagonist but it is not like he is top 10 antagonists in OP or anything.

-14

u/Open_Inspector_7863 Sep 07 '24

There was no indication you cognitively superior highschooler. But yeah, enjoy.

8

u/sami_newgate Sep 08 '24

That’s what those who lack reading comprehension usually say.