When Micah was picked up by Pinkertons

[u/ImAgIrAfFe72]

This may seem a bit far fetched so strap in guys, it’s a weird one. (Excuse the rubbish format, I’m on mobile.)

So, we know Micah was picked up by the Pinkertons right after Guarma, yeah? And as you don’t retrieve your horse until a little bit later, you can steal one. Now to me, it seems the player is directed to a specific horse hitched outside the bar (is it Annesburg or Van Horn? I can’t remember) and that horse is a tobiano Hungarian Half-Bred.

However, during the Chapter Two mission ‘The Sheep and the Goats’, you can see a Pinkerton agent next to Cornwall, saddled on a tobiano Hungarian Half-Bred. This horse is pretty hard to find unless you’re extremely lucky and find one at a camp or nab one off a bounty hunter, so we know they’re not super common and are kind of exclusive to these characters, right?

SO, my line of thought is, an agent could’ve been inside the town’s bar and that’s where Micah was grabbed- maybe the horse you can steal is a Pinkerton’s and that’s why you don’t lose honour for taking it as you would by stealing an ‘innocent’s’; also, Micah takes a while compared to others to reach Lakay, but I realise this could be down to not knowing where the gang was holed up at the time and I’m just grasping at straws or something.

I feel like this isn’t just a random coincidence because, y’know, it’s Rockstar and I thought it would be a pretty neat thing, like a red herring, maybe?

But, thanks for coming to my Ted Talk, please tell me your thoughts!

[u/Hardie1247]

Im honestly convinced that it had nothing to do with Micah at all, at least not to begin with, and that's why the extent of Micah's involvement was left so open ended. The Pinkertons claim that Micah was picked up upon their return from Guarma, however there are tip-offs towards the heist which sends them there, as if the Pinkertons were informed of when and where they should be prepared for the bank heist to happen, prior to speaking to Micah at all.

This makes me wonder whether "Micah is a rat" was a lie from the start, spread by the Pinkertons to cause distrust amongst the gang, which they knew was already falling apart due to a potential other informant?

[u/jordan_bris → u/Hardie1247]

Theres a theory that Abigail was the real rat and that's why you dont see her during the bank heist and why she kills milton at the end so he doesnt expose her

[u/J_rd_nn → u/jordan_bris]

You're onto something, but the catch is, Abigail knew that John was obligated to participate in the robbery. She still loved John despite her actions. She would indirectly cause John to be killed, leaving Jack with no father, and possibly no Mother if she thought Milton was going to kill her too for even being an associate.

[u/jordan_bris → u/J_rd_nn]

But the pinkertons could have easily just killed john like they did lenny and hosea. By working with them Abigail might have insured his safety as a price for her help

[u/andrecinno → u/jordan_bris]

Insured his safety? He was bound to be hanged.

[u/jordan_bris → u/andrecinno]

I thought he was just put in the big prison.was that not the alternative to hanging because he was in there for a while

[u/andrecinno → u/jordan_bris]

He was supposed to hang some time after you bust him out.

[u/jordan_bris → u/andrecinno]

Well there goes that theory. I still always thought it was micah but it was a fun one to contemplate