r/Political_Revolution Feb 09 '23

Video Questioning Matt Walsh’s credentials

114 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-8

u/Voat-the-Goat Feb 10 '23

Credentials are controlled by the authority.

11

u/Kr155 Feb 10 '23

AN authority, not THE Authority.

In this case a medical board after a process to make sure you're qualified to be a medical professional.

-1

u/Technical_Anxiety_41 Feb 10 '23

a medical board that so full of redundant, unnecessary red tape, beaurocracy, and over-regulation that the supply of doctors is low. half the shit in this has NOTHING to do with the ability of a doctor to provide adequate care.

The overregulation of the healthcare industry by lobbying is why we have the most insane healthcare costs in the US

1

u/Kr155 Feb 11 '23

Yes we should do away with the medical boards and go back to the days of patent medicine. Can't wait to be able to buy MMS and horse pills from Facebook mom groups.

If you want to clear up some useless red tape, eliminate the reduce the profit motive. Then I'm with you. If you want to defund and abolish institutions altogether, then you're just plain dumb.

1

u/Technical_Anxiety_41 Feb 12 '23

i want to abolish institutions that only exist becasue of lobbying and not to provide any utility

1

u/Kr155 Feb 12 '23

only exist becasue of lobbying and not to provide any utility

And you believe that describes state medical boards... do you have something else you would replace that with?

1

u/Technical_Anxiety_41 Feb 12 '23

yes, youre missing the point....

I wouldnt replace it because IT DOESN'T DO ANYTHING, it doesnt need replacing because its a money PIT

Medical school ensures competent doctors, they can even issue diplomas that double as a license, because graduating med school and being liscnesed by some arbitrary government guidelines.....well theres not really a stretch there

and if a doctor is guilty of malpractice, you dont need a fucking dedicated medical board to discipline him, THATS WHY WE HAVE COURTS AND A CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

The medical boards are 100000% just a redundant waste of tax money of systems we ALREADY have in place.

they exist ONLY to make the barrier to entry into medical care higher, and consequently drive medical care costs through te roof

1

u/Kr155 Feb 13 '23

I didn't miss the point, I asked you to confirm before I just assumed.

So instead of requiring a residency where a doctor or surgeon practices under the supervision of a professional you would have them finish med school then go straight to practicing/cutting. You would have a system where once you finish med school you would become a doctor for life, with no governing body responsible to ensure you've maintained practice and continued your education. Instead of professional experts who are trained and practice medicine themselves who have the ability to remove someone's ability to practice medicine. The only method for punishing a doctor would be to sue them financially, you would leave no way to take away someone's ability to practice medicine. What about the school. Would there be some way for the government to determine the education was legitimate? Who in the government now determines the school is a real medical school and not a mail order homeopathy academy? Or do we just wait for someone with enough money to hire a lawyer to sue when thier kid gets gangrene and is treated with especially oils, and trust that the 94 year old judge who learned to treat a cold with onions in his socks is going to rule with sense? Just curious

-1

u/Technical_Anxiety_41 Feb 13 '23

You would have a system where once you finish med school you would become a doctor for life, with no governing body responsible to ensure you've maintained practice and continued your education. Instead of professional experts who are trained and practice medicine themselves who have the ability to remove someone's ability to practice medicine.

yes, and id also make residency a part of medical school since the fact they are seperate is stupid. although residency would mostly just be for doctors who do things that are invasive

The only method for punishing a doctor would be to sue them financially, you would leave no way to take away someone's ability to practice medicine.

i see where ur coming from but that shouldn't be a government issue....I have broken many computers in my life.... should I get my ability to be an electrical engineer taken away? You can practice, but if you kill someone youll just be in jail, and then have no customers.... so i dont see a problem there.

What about the school. Would there be some way for the government to determine the education was legitimate?

Who determines if my engineering degree is legitimate? My school has to go through some bullshit arbitrary qualifications for "accreditation". To my knowledge these are mostly performative and not based on anything...just more bureaucracy, but if we can make accreditation actually.....MEANINGFUL, i dont have an issue with accrediting med school as well, just like any college

Who in the government now determines the school is a real medical school and not a mail order homeopathy academy?

I mean... government approval of schools comes down to who bribes them, not by adhering to any standards. Unfortunately education is largely a compromised institution, so I dont see this last point as meaningful. But again, if accreditation makes you sleep better (even though its meaningless), we can do that sure