r/reddeadredemption • u/Finn_Flame • Aug 20 '24

Video The duality of Arthur Morgan

6.6k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

135 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/Tamer9 Aug 21 '24

The dialogues don’t seem as canon. It’s like Arthur is trying too hard to be mean.

1

u/ghost_of_Theweb Aug 22 '24

That's how canonically Arthur used to be, before getting tuberculosis because that's when he started to rethink his life choices.

0

u/Tamer9 Aug 22 '24

I’m sorry but Arthur before TB would embrace Tilly in that moment; not be aloof and dismissive. The high honour cutscenes are way more realistic and canon IMO.

1

u/ghost_of_Theweb Aug 23 '24

The high honor events are canon only AFTER the TB event, but before that Arthur had still the mindset of an outlaw and a murder, but again that was before his redemption ark