r/reddeadredemption Jun 25 '23

Speculation How It Should Have Ended

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Zilla96 Dutch van der Linde Jun 26 '23

Arthur has fallen for Dutchs charm. He has a gambler's fallacy or just "one more heist and we go to Tahiti. It's going to go smoothly son, not like blackwater". She's too optimistic about living a normal life with him because he will be chased to the ends of the earth. Even if Arthur survived ,John may have killed him on the Vanderlin hit lost of RDR1.