r/reddeadredemption Jun 25 '23

Speculation How It Should Have Ended

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

View all comments

767

u/Spyro390 Sadie Adler Jun 26 '23

Not that their lifestyles would’ve worked together but if Arthur and Mary did run away together I’d like to think that Sadie, john and his family went with them and they made a new life ranching or something.

238

u/detectivelokifalcone Jun 26 '23

yes totally would run away together but not ranchers. Arthur would be a explorer / surveyor based on his artwork and comprehensive writing skill, John I don't know too much about him but he definitely could be his wing man and probably pick up a few things from Arthur

184

u/Spyro390 Sadie Adler Jun 26 '23

Both Arthur and John have worked ranches as young boys, John is obviously suited to the work as we see at the end of the game and Arthur basically keeps camp afloat himself. Arthur could be an artist though for sure.

16

u/FullHouse222 Jun 26 '23

I never got the sense that John was suited for ranch work. One of the running jokes at pronghorn was that he would starve if he ran a ranch and he basically purchased Beecher's hope which was a massive scam of a property since literally no one else who knew what they were doing wanted it. He did enough to get by and feed his family but they weren't like the Geddes who were successful in running a ranch to become somewhat wealthy as known by the Geddes position in Strawberry