r/reddeadmysteries • u/Satsloader PS4 • Nov 21 '18

Resource Roanoke Whispers Explained!

I ran across this video on YouTube (linked by Justin Kern in El Chiefo Network comments) which clearly explains the whispers heard in the woods (almost verbatim), and the Lore behind this ghostly event. If you watch this video, you could speculate there is more to this Easter Egg and a marching Ghostly British army can be found somewhere nearby - but I’d have thought by now someone would discover this.

Lore Source: In-game Movie Theater “The Ghastly Serenade” movie.

Male Ghost Voice: Eugene Hutton

Female Ghost Voice: Ethel Boshared

Video Explains Lore from whispers courtesy of SeanEazy: https://youtu.be/sKXy_rXkYH4

Here’s is the location of of the whispers, which can be heard during day or night: https://socialclub.rockstargames.com/photo/rdr2/5eoEGCdEukiF37PGHAUdYQ

Recording of the whispers and analysis by El Chiefo Network: https://youtu.be/wRjVfMPRL8U

184 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

41 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Killspree90 Nov 22 '18 edited Nov 23 '18

Something to note here. There is a random encounter where a person appears headless on a horse in that same area.... Related? Did the ghost army cut off his head too?

Edit: further detail on the encounter. You just see someone walking a horse and they have no head.. The horse keeps going for a bit then the body just falls off the horse eventually.

7

u/holliday50 Nov 25 '18

I'm fairly sure this is just somebody you run into that had a bad encounter with Murfree Brothers. I definitely saw it myself and that was my first thought. Kind of like running into people slouched on their horses with arrows in their backs in Skinner territory.

2

u/Tacdelio Dec 03 '18

Oddly enough, the guy with the arrows in his back is alive. i shot him and lost honor :( or it was a glitch.

3

u/_Shinogenu_ Dec 22 '18

Late but yoy lose honor for disrespecting the dead, unless they’re enemies like Murfrees or something. Also lose honor for shooting the body at the pagan ritual