I (23M) am a gay guy who grew up in the Appalachian/Bible Belt region fo the US. A relatively small town, rural, conservative, traditional, Christian area - essentially, even though I came out when I was 14, I've never been in a relationship or been on a date or, honestly, have never been pursued romantically in my life.
Which has been fine. I'm not a very extroverted or social person to begin with, so I've become very independent and used to being single/alone, and while I've sometimes wished to be able to experience love, I've surrounded myself with close friends and family who are able to somewhat fill that void in my life.
But, then....enter E (29M).
He joined my office about three months ago for a temp position and we immediately hit it off. When I say hit it off, I mean I've never felt so comfortable around a guy before. I grew up with all girls for friends, was raised by a single mom and a grandmother - I've never been comfortable around guys, but E is different. I could almost immediately be myself around him, which is a feat in itself, and our interests/personalities just mesh so well. I was honestly happy that I could have maybe found a new friend.
I didn't realize it at first, but E has been very flirty with me from the get-go. At first I just thought it was teasing or banter, but my friends and coworkers were all like "no....babe, he's like, flirting heavy." And every time I'm around E, there's so much eye contact between us. It almost put me off at first because, again, I've never been super sociable and have always hated eye contact. But with E, it had this....pull to it, like this intensity that I've never felt before with eye contact. A coworker who I'm super close with said that whenever I'm talking, E is focused so intently on me that there's almost a spark in his eyes. When I changed my appearance a few weeks ago, another coworker and I went to E's office to chat, and even though our other coworker was standing right in front of him talking to him, he was looking right at me off to the side the entire time - at my new hairstyle (it was a perm, so it definitely was a big change).
That's always been the case with E, even now - his temp position's time came to an end but we still keep in touch and still hang out. We were hanging out all the time before the holidays; my best friend said I see E more than she sees her long-term boyfriend. I've caught him checking me out at least once or twice, I believe. He remembers the craziest little details about me and has pointed out small physical things about me that no one else as pointed out before. He's very chivalrous - holds doors open, cleans up trash for me after we go out to eat, always offers to hold my bag when I go to the restroom - but he's also ex-military, so I don't know if that's just a respect thing he's been taught or not.
The one time he came to pick me up for a hang-out, he came up to my front door and rang the doorbell and waited for me on the front porch. I've never had a friend do that before. Everyone else has always parked and texted that they were there. I swear, I felt like I was being picked up for a date.
Hell, a few weeks ago he sent me a post on Instagram that read "I don't flirt, I just say every thought I have and hope for the best." I didn't think much of it at the time, but now I'm wondering if he sent that as some sort of message? All my friends say no straight guy sends that to another guy friend - their straight boyfriends agreed.
And because of all this, of course I've grown feelings for him. He's always on my mind, I always get so excited when his name pops up on my phone. I never wanted to act on them when he was a coworker, but because I was ignoring them, they've festered into this beast.
But here's the issue: E has never explicitly said he's into guys, but I've never explicitly asked, and he's openly talked about women to me before - both exes he's had and women who've caught his attention and, again, funny "meme" posts on Instagram that also talk about being with women. He knows I'm gay and I've talked about being gay once or twice with him, and once his response seemed very....personal? He wasn't talking about himself but it was almost as if he was talking from experience. Again though, that's it. He's never made any physical advances outside a few friendly touches. He's also not a big texter - more often than not, he leaves me on read unless I'm explicitly asking him a question, but he's expressed before that he's not great at texting. We do keep in contact at least once a day, usually by sending each other stuff on social media.
Also, about a month ago when I was really telling myself "he's straight, he's straight, get over yourself" I was open with him about being active on dating apps. During this time, it did feel like he somewhat pulled back from me a bit - we still kept in touch, but it felt like we lost that spark we had in the beginning. However, recently, that spark came back in full force - especially the last time we got together. I swear, it felt like something between us was starting to shift toward something more than friends. But then the holidays hit and I haven't seen him in just over a week, and it might be another week or so until he's back in town, so I don't know if what I felt was a fluke or not.
So I don't know what to do. I'm getting to the point where these feelings are real, big, and consuming, and all the mixed signals (if you can even call them that) are so confusing.
I've told myself that I can't make a first move, because I don't want to scare him off in case I'm reading everything wrong and I'm really starting to value having him in my life. E has also told me, on multiple occasions, that he isn't good at picking up hints - usually he doesn't even know someone is interested in him until after the fact because someone else saw the hints and told him. So I believe me trying to "drop hints" myself won't be productive.
So.....do I sit back and wait it out more? See if anything really develops? Or should I start thinking about, well, not making the first move so to speak, but just opening up the conversation between us? If so, how does one even do that?
Thank you so much in advance for any advice!
TLDR: My (23M) new-ish friend (29M) gives me mixed signals that he might be into me. It's caused me to grow feelings for him, feelings that are starting to become real/more than a crush I think. On the one hand, he has shown enough "interest" in me that other people have picked up on it; on the other, he's never explicitly said he's into guys, though I've never outright asked him. What do I do, if anything, about this?