r/JewsOfConscience Jew of Color Jun 29 '24

Activism NYC Dyke March Drama

The NYC Dyke March is being boycotted by many other organizations including Act Up NYC for putting out and subsequently deleting this statement. Thoughts?

Imma be real I don't really think this statement is bad at all, but I understand that others have read it as "all lives matter"-ing the genocide in Gaza. Would love to hear more takes.

131 Upvotes

135 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Specialist-Gur Ashkenazi Jun 30 '24

Well, even though I agree that antisemtism is a problem and I don’t agree this post is bad.. it’s complicated.

The level of antisemitic incidents is complex.. 1. Jews are more likely to report to police than other groups such as Muslims. 2. The definition of antisemtism is incredibly loosey goosey.. which I take major issue with

The other thing is.. as others laid out, not all the victims on October 7th were Jewish. And most Zionists aren’t Jewish. I think the critical piece here is that isrsel/palestine really isn’t a Jewish issue.. and making it one is frustrating. And I agree with that. This post just plays into the idea that anti Israel messaging is scary for Jews.

However. Jewish people are terrified and are afraid.. and do feel uncomfortable with anti Israel messaging… therefore I see nothing wrong with a message acknowledging this and welcoming Jews specifically and also letting them know there is room for empathy for them while supporting Palestinians.

It’s a complex issue. I think the Jewish who are uncomfortable at queer events because of the support for Palestine need to self reflect. But at the same time, I see nothing wrong with the events trying to meet them where they are at

1

u/PossibleDeer4613 Jun 30 '24

Ah I misunderstood you.

Can you elaborate what you mean by most Zionists aren’t Jewish?

1

u/Specialist-Gur Ashkenazi Jun 30 '24

Most Zionists in America are Christians by far. Also the definition of “Zionists” are so broad.. there are Jewish people who call themselves Zionist who want a 1ss and just think that Zionism means Jewish self determination. These people are misinformed but I think that adds a layer of fuzziness to the analysis of how many Zionists are Jews and how many Jews are Zionist

2

u/PossibleDeer4613 Jun 30 '24

I see. Yes- Zionists and Anti-Zionist define zionism differently. By both self-definitions I am an anti-zionist zionist 🫠. I actually think that the word Zionism being an amorphous thing is a huge part of the vitriol- there are a lot of people in the middle who dont know they basically agree on 60-70% of things but are labeling themselves differently, and then making assumptions about “the other side”.

1

u/Specialist-Gur Ashkenazi Jul 01 '24

Oh I totally agree with you. I feel like I’m not being clear in most of my comments on this thread and it’s rubbing people the wrong way.. but I also am totally against Zionism and do not agree it’s an amorphous thing. I just think that there are Jewish people that are less politically informed at the moment but probably would get to where we are too