I'm planning to travel to the Netherlands (and back) next summer for a few days with my partner. I've done Zürich/Basel to Amsterdam and back a few times via Frankfurt and it was quite eventful to say the least. That was fine when I was travelling alone with little lugagge, but for our short vacation together, I'm not sure we're up for the challenge.
First of all, I love trains and I would travel anywhere by train if it was possible. My main concern is, that we spend half of our short vacation stuck on the German rails. For this trip the rain ride is not supposed to be part of the experience, but just get us from A to B as fast and reliable as possible.
So these are all the options I came up with and I would like to hear your experiences and recommendations for us. (We're probably buying single tickets far in advance so we can ignore passholder reservations etc. for the moment)
ICE Zürich - Frankfurt then ICE Frankfurt - Amsterdam
Scheduled Duration: 9.5 hours (based on my past experience closer to 12 hours in reality)
That's my usual route, with a planned connection time of 1.5 hours in Frankfurt. You'd be surprised (or not, depending how often you travel in Germany) how often I actually didn't make my connecting train. Bonus points if the next ICE to the Netherlands is cancelled (RE19 from Düsseldorf to Arnhem has saved me quite often).
I thought about going to Frankfurt in the evening and then going to the Netherlands the next day, but that doesn't really work with our schedule.
TGV Zürich - Paris GdL then Eurostar Paris-Nord - Amsterdam
Scheduled Duration: 8.25 Hours
I've never taken a train in France, so I don't know about the reliability there. My main concern here is switching stations in Paris which seems like a hassle. But this might be a viable alternative to the Frankfurt route if French trains are more reliable.
NighJet Zürich - Amsterdam
Scheduled Duration: 12 Hours (Doesn't really matter as it's overnight)
I've taken this train before. When it runs as planned it's nice, but it rarely does. Sleeper/couchette carriages break down and get replaced by seating cars quite frequently. Not an experience I'm looking to repeat. If it was reliable, this would be my train of choice every time though.
Flight Zürich - Amsterdam
Scheduled Duration: 1.5 hours + 3 hours for airport stuff and transit from and to the airport
I hate flying, even more so within Europe. Even though overall travel time is about half that of trains, I dislike the whole airport stuff so much. Sadly it does seem like the most reliable and least stressful option in this case.
I'm curious to hear what all of you think about these options!