Originally posted here: https://short-and-sweet-movie-reviews.blogspot.com/2024/12/mary-2024-movie-review.html
The Netflix biblical epic "Mary" is a retelling of the story of Mary and Joseph and the birth of Jesus. It's based on The Gospel of James or Protoevangelium of James, an apocryphal or non-canonical gospel, so don't be surprised if many of the events and characters portrayed on screen diverge from the familiar Bible teachings. It's an odd choice that is bound to irritate religious conservatives who will probably not be able to watch this one all the way through. However, that's not even the movie's worst offense.
Billed by the streamer as a "timeless coming-of-age story", it feels more like a comic bok origin story, with hilariously over-the-top scenes, like a schlocky showdown between Lucifer and the angel Gabriel, which veer on self-parody. It's never a good sign when it feels like you're watching an episode of "Supernatural". For those of you out there who think the Bible narrative is nonsensical, Netflix seemed determined to one-up it with mind-boggling plot developments, cartoonish characters and action sequences that feel completely out of place.
It's overblown, full of its own importance, and completely oblivious to how unintentionally funny it gets when it sacrifices depth in favor of faux-epicness. The acting is flat and uninspiring. Relative newcomer Noa Cohen as Mary has little to offer other than wide-eyed numbness and a gaping void of emotion. She's clearly out of her depth, but I suppose it's hard to blame the actors when the writing and dialogue are horrendous and the characters so hollow. It's not even an exaggeration, Timothy Michael Hayes' script has some of the worst lines of dialogue I've heard in a long time.
Casting Anthony Hopkins as the tyrannical King Herod is possibly the only thing this movie did right. The actor is a miracle of God, and the only entertaining thing about this 100-minute ordeal. I can't say he gives the movie a redeeming quality, because he's not really that much in it, but I will say you will spend most of this movie's running time wishing it had more King Herod and less Mary.
On a technical level, everything about this so-called Biblical epic screams "made for streaming". The cinematography and art direction are generically competent, but still underwhelming. The costumes are adequate for a period piece, apart from some headwear designs that feel more at home in Denis Villeneuve's "Dune". You'll know them when you see them. The original score by Timothy Williams swells with orchestral aplomb throughout, but it's undermined by the lack of a memorable main theme and by the movie's overall lack of emotional depth.
To my surprise, the film is directed by D.J. Caruso, who is best known for helming "The Salton Sea", "Taking Lives", "Disturbia" and "Eagle Eye". I've always thought of him as a competent director, capable of turning drivel into something watchable or at the very least mildly entertaining. That's not the case with "Mary", which I'm sad to say is the worst film I've watched in 2024. Don't even bother with this one. Just watch "The Nativity Story" or, better yet, the "Jesus of Nazareth" miniseries.