r/HomeworkHelp • u/latinqvarters • 28m ago
Mathematics (Tertiary/Grade 11-12)—Pending OP [University Math/Logical Reasoning] Is my line of reasoning for this question sound/valid?
Question:
The Sustainability Club has recently elected new officers, including Sophia, Hana, Wolt, and Joshua, who assumed the roles of president, vice president, secretary, and treasurer. In the context of a provided set of clues, ascertain the appropriate logical reasoning approach to determine the specific positions held by each elected officer. You can use any type of visual representations to solve this problem.
i. Joshua is younger than the president but older than the treasurer.
ii. Sophia and the secretary are both the same age, and they are the youngest members of the group.
iii. Wolt and the secretary are next-door neighbours.
My Answer:
Table of Elimination #1:
Name/Position | Joshua | Wolt | Sophia | Hana |
---|---|---|---|---|
President | X | |||
Vice president | ||||
Secretary | X | X | ||
Treasurer | X |
Order of age: President(?) > ?(Joshua) > Treasurer(?), Secretary(?) = Sophia(?)
Since Joshua is older than the treasurer but younger than the president, he can't be either of them, nor the secretary as they are the youngest. Hence, Joshua is the vice president.
Wolt can't be the secretary because he's mentioned to be the neighbour of the secretary. Though Sophia and the secretary are the same age, I assume this means that they are different people.
Table of Elimination #2:
Name/Position | Joshua | Wolt | Sophia | Hana |
---|---|---|---|---|
President | X | |||
Vice president | ✅ | X | X | X |
Secretary | X | X | X | |
Treasurer | X |
Order of age #2: President(?) > VP(Joshua) > Treasurer(?), Secretary(?) = ?(Sophia)
Since Sophia and the secretary are the youngest, there's no way for Sophia to be the president (who is the oldest). Assuming that the secretary and Sophia are different people, then she also can't be the secretary. Hence, Sophia is the treasurer.
Table of Elimination #3:
Name/Position | Joshua | Wolt | Sophia | Hana |
---|---|---|---|---|
President | X | X | X | |
Vice president | ✅ | X | X | X |
Secretary | X | X | X | |
Treasurer | X | X | ✅ | X |
Order of age #3: President(?) > VP(Joshua) > Treasurer(Sophia), Secretary(?) = Treasurer(Sophia)
Hence, Wolt is the president, and Hana is the secretary.
Order of age #4: President(Wolt) > VP(Joshua) > Treasurer(Sophia), Secretary(Hana)