36
u/Falconpunch7593 Mar 06 '23
If I remember correctly GTA,Manhunt,bully all take place in the same universe Red dead redemption takes place in its own universe
13
4
u/InSan1tyWeTrust Mar 06 '23
Pretty sure they all take part in the same universe. With some of the wackiness in RDR I can't see how that 1800s world wouldn't evolve into GTA.
Also pretty sure there are RDR references in GTA so that's enough of a link for me.
9
u/avoltaire12 Mar 06 '23 edited Mar 06 '23
Red Dead Redemption I and II explicitly mention New York and San Francisco in their dialogue so unless these cities are supposed to co-exist with their GTA counterparts Liberty City and San Fierro (which would be odd), RDR is probably in its own universe. There's an RDR book on the shelves of Franklin's house in GTA V but I think this is more of an easter egg than anything serious.
9
u/EvDogster Mar 06 '23
That's a good point. Maybe RDR, LA Noir, and Max Payne all take place in the same universe considering they all use the real name of cities. That might be a stretch tho
4
2
Mar 07 '23
I know of a book in some bookshelves, written by a J. Marston… can’t recall the name of it, but in Franklin’s Aunt Denise’s house I recall seeing one.
7
u/tearful_muffin Mar 06 '23
Well, epsilon appears in RDR2
2
u/EvDogster Mar 07 '23
Maybe epsilon is a mutli universal cult lol Wasn't the one member in RDR2 a time traveler or something
17
Mar 06 '23
Carcer city is mentioned in GTA 5 by Michael if I remember correct, during the Paleto Score. It all takes place in the same universe.
7
3
u/Lord-Reign Mar 07 '23
Carcer City is meant to be Chicago right?
5
u/EvDogster Mar 07 '23
Online it says it's close to Liberty City. Mostly saying a city in Ohio. My guess is Cleveland
5
u/AllStarSuperman_ Mar 06 '23
Would be awesome if more of a crossover between Manhunt and San Andreas. JEC having a history with Tenpenny or Carl encountering the Cerberus soldiers.
5
2
u/Caiomoriarty May 01 '23
Thats what i talk about in the manhunt sub,cash should have make at least one appareance in GTA San Andreas or some citation,like a mission where we save him from the SA police or crossing path with him in some cutscene,also hiring him to killing someone would be a good idea too. O wonder if cash ever met tenpenny or the truth off screen
2
u/AllStarSuperman_ May 01 '23
After reading through the comments here, it would fit better for Cash and Claude to meet, LC is apparently closer to Carcer than San Andreas. Not to mention both 3 and Manhunt take place “present day” early 2000s.
With that in mind, it would be awesome if Cash was the reason for Donald Loves disappearance. Maybe have Donald Love involved in the Starkweather storyline.
1
2
u/wickedbl0ke Mar 06 '23
R* will probably make another bunch of millions if they just start making energy drinks.
2
u/cjtangmi Mar 06 '23
What are the odds Carcer city make it into one of the expansions to GTAVI? I don't think it's unrealistic.
1
u/malaka3000 Mar 06 '23
perhaps not unrealistic, but not very likely imo
1
u/the123king-reddit Mar 06 '23
I dont think it’s unreasonable to think a GTA game could be set in Carcer City…
Whats its IRL counterpart? Chicago?
1
u/EvDogster Mar 07 '23 edited Mar 07 '23
Research online says it's close to Liberty City Mostly saying some city in Ohio. My guess is Cleveland
-5
1
1
u/TheJackoHype Mar 06 '23
There's the 2D universe, 3D universe HD Universe, then I think Read Dead is in its own universe
1
1
60
u/fieldysnuts94 Mar 06 '23
Yeah it’s the same universe. The stats in GTA 4 mention carcer city in the “miles traveled” stats if you drive enough