James Dillard Dutton from 1883. Can you guess which one is the game capture?

[u/euphorinc]

[u/scampsalot2]

The one that looks like a video game

[u/Aristotle_Ninja2]

The one in the middle

[u/dffttffff]

The one thats clearly the video game

[u/hemlock_tea64]

the one on the right

[u/GOATonWii → u/hemlock_tea64]

i can only tell because of john’s scar

and the belt

[u/hemlock_tea64 → u/GOATonWii]

i mean the image on the left contains no items from the game while i can name everything in the picture on the right. then theres the dumb gunbelt position on the hip and the dumber holster on the front of it

[u/hemlock_tea64 → u/hemlock_tea64]

and the clothes all fit perfectly in the picture on the right

[u/zack_hunter → u/hemlock_tea64]

Well they are tailormade

[u/lewispyrah → u/GOATonWii]

And you know... literally everything else

[u/Billib2002]

Yes we can guess which one is the game capture man😭

[u/ChanceyJC]

Pretty easy to tell when rockstar gave us the weird ass offhand

[u/mrsomething4]

Wow that is a tricky one

[u/Musical-Elk-629]

Lol the only way i could recognize the game version was because of the textures-otherwise uou wouldve completely had me stuck..

[u/Apprehensive-Cow-798]

The clothes in game (vest) don't fold as detaild as they do irl, dead giveaway.

[u/TxEagleDeathclaw81]

Phenomenal job! Looks kick ass!

[u/Sea-Interaction2050]

What vest is that?

[u/pittsburghpirates11]

Right only because the dumb cross draw holster

[u/itchypantz]

That colour photography from 1883 was ON POINT! I can't tell the difference!

[u/eversunday298]

I LOVE THIS 😭

[u/Jormundagiir]

The one on the right is in game because of the floating horse reins. They aren't resting on the neck like they would in real life.

[u/Neurodos]

I would also think the grass is a giveaway considering video games still have trouble making 100% real looking grass and the one on the right seems to stick out as being in game.

[u/niv13]

Just look at the holster and you'll get your answer

[u/Covy_Killer]

Bro his thumb and finger are clipping in the one on the right.

[u/reddit_understoodit]

Snake hips on the right

[u/Valuable-Policy-7620]

What’s the shirt

[u/KingGannicus916]

Is this outfit able to be re-created without mods?

[u/euphorinc → u/KingGannicus916]

I'm not using any mods

[u/Jimmilton102]

I would never guess which one is the videogame,NEVER.

[u/I-am-the-milkman]

One on the left. How can yall not tell that it’s the one on the left smh my head.

[u/sjoerddadutchturtle → u/I-am-the-milkman]

Reminder that smh means 'shaking my head' and that you're currently shaking your head your head

[u/paco987654 → u/sjoerddadutchturtle]

r/woosh

[u/I-am-the-milkman → u/sjoerddadutchturtle]

Ong?

[u/sjoerddadutchturtle → u/I-am-the-milkman]

Ong on god

[u/I-am-the-milkman → u/sjoerddadutchturtle]

Crazy business

[u/CoolPicturesMan → u/I-am-the-milkman]

LOL don't people understand sarcasm.

[u/I-am-the-milkman → u/CoolPicturesMan]

People just be grumpy on this sub

[u/reddit_understoodit → u/CoolPicturesMan]

I live for sarcasm, but we can't hear it on here.