r/onebagging • u/tellmetheworld • Jun 13 '18
Gear I’m torn between the 45l Tortuga outbreaker and the Patagonia blackhole mlc
Hello!
I’m going on a massive one month trip and want to pack as smartly as possible since I’ll be taking lots of public transport and don’t want to wheel a bag through the monsoon streets of India. I’m a smaller female so weight is a concern of mine and both of these backpacks seem to have pluses and minuses. I’ve heard great things about both and would love some extra perspective from this subreddit:)
I ordered both to physically compare and need to send one back. Here is what I observed from both.
Tortuga: pros: love the hip straps and the waterproof plus lockable zippers! I also like how the interior organizer on the front pocket stays upright as you carry it. It has a nice water bottle holder!
Cons: it’s very heavy unpacked! Also I wonder if it’s a bit over engineered for my needs since I won’t have a laptop.
PATAGONIA MLC: Pros: I prefer this interior organization better as far as zippering off both compartments like a suitcase would. You could open it up without stuff falling out. I also like how it has a shoulder strap for the days where I’ll have my day pack on my shoulders but the bag ready to put in the van. Not sure how to manage both at the same time otherwise.
Cons: but I don’t like how the internal organization pocket turns sideways when worn as a backpack. Also I don’t think I’ll be walking around for more than a half hour with it but I am worried about discomfort since I’m fairly small (5’ 3”) and not a muscular person. I wish the zippers were lockable and waterproof.
2
u/ContentFarmer Jun 13 '18
Get both.
2
u/tellmetheworld Jun 13 '18
Oh man, don’t tempt me. I quit my job to take this trip and should probably stick with one but I would be lying if the thought didn’t cross my mind!
1
Jun 13 '18
It’s less space for carry on and more weight with a 45L back. International fights have VERY strict weight limits, often as low as 7kg (common on the Asian airlines I fly often). Sometimes you are lucky and sometimes not.
1
u/bookmonkey786 Jun 13 '18
For someone your size go smaller 30-35 is the sweet spot. You don't want more then a week's worth of clothes, various odd and end and maybe a light laptop.
Do a test pack and see ho much room your stuff will take up then select a bag based on that.
1
u/theninthcl0ud Jun 13 '18
I prefer lighter bags especially when they get schlepped around a lot. That said backpack MLC is uncomfortable with weight. No outbreaker experience for me. Cotopaxi allpa is neat, in my opinion though
1
u/Smashleyyyyy Jun 13 '18
I had a lot of issues with my cotopaxi allpa in terms of fit. Lots of reviewers love it though but something to keep in mind. I really love the outbreaker because you can dial in the straps to fit perfectly.
That being said OP i am selling an allpa if interested :)
1
u/theninthcl0ud Jun 13 '18
Ah, hrm that hasn't been a problem for me, being 5' 7" 150lb. So maybe it's not universal? Anywho, I guess if OP is more interested he or she can ask about the Allpa.
1
u/arkwhaler Jun 13 '18
Have you looked at the tom bihn aeronaut? They are now shipping with an option for hip belt and removable internal frame. They aren't exactly suitcase packable but they have many organizational options and are tough.
Going another direction the osprey farpoint/Fairview offers a different opening than traditional tubular backpack, but still affords good suspension and female-fit options.
1
u/walnut100 Jun 13 '18
If you aren't completely tech-ed out then I advise against the Outbreaker. It's designed for obsessive tech organization. The Tortuga Setout is supposed to come back into stock next week and is just one giant pocket that's less than half the weight of the Outbreaker. Tom Bihn Aeronaut is also a great choice, if not a bit ugly.
Also, at your height a 45L bag is going to be massive on you. If you can swing something smaller, the Cotopaxi Alpa may be perfect for you.
1
u/benalene Jun 13 '18
I am a 5'1" woman, and I am looking for a bag that is less than 30L! I can't imagine going all the way up to 45L! A bag with a hip belt will greatly help with the weight, though. I would highly recommend test packing both bags with all the stuff you are planning to bring, and then carrying them around the house or around the block to get a feel for what it is like to really carry the bag since you are concerned about the weight. You might find that your comfort level when carrying the bag is more important than internal organization.
1
u/Smashleyyyyy Jun 13 '18
I have a tortuga outbreaker and like it a lot. I do agree with everyone else here - the 35L is probably better for you. I have a 45L at 5'7" and while it doesn't feel too big I could definitely get away with the 35L.
I really don't think much of the MLC - I've not tried it but it just doesn't look like it would be fun to carry. My opinion is you really don't want to resent your bag a week into your trip.
TL;DR I'd consider the outbreaker 35L OR tortuga setout. If you need to pick between the two you have in-hand keep the 45L outbreaker.
Also since others mentioned it the cotopaxi allpa is a really, really great bag. I loved carrying it but the fit was off enough that I wound up picking up an outbreaker instead. I'm selling my allpa if you read reviews and want to try it out. The organization is fantastic and I'm a huge fan of the company. My review here: https://www.reddit.com/r/onebag/comments/890oyz/travel_bag_i_havent_seen_mentioned_much_cotopaxi/
1
Jun 19 '18 edited Jun 22 '18
[deleted]
1
u/Smashleyyyyy Jun 19 '18
https://www.reddit.com/r/onebagging/comments/89qvs2/cotopaxi_allpa_review_was_deleted_from_ronebag/
It didn't fit me perfectly. With the sternum strap it was super easy to carry but I don't like using those if I can avoid it. I'm selling mine - if you want one let me know.
1
u/2dP_rdg Jun 25 '18
Get the MLC -
I'm currently selling my 45L Outbreaker.. I used it for a 3 week international trip and never noticed the weight of the bag thanks to the hip straps. But you lose a lot of space to the laptop compartment which is a waste if you're not carrying one.
1
u/DarumaRed Jun 27 '18
Have you considered the 45L Tortuga Setout? When trying bags I found the Outbreaker to be far too large (even the 35L) but the Setout cinches down nicely when it isn't bursting. Granted, I am 6'2" so a bigger bag works better for me, but the weight is also a huge advantage over the Outbreaker.
1
u/Semisonic Jul 22 '18
Why the MLC over just a small black hole duffel?
The 45L is a great little bag, and IMO the smaller black hole duffels are pretty worthy backpacks for the limited walking you’re doing. Very light weight.
I def would have cross-shipped it with my TB Aeronaut if I had known they came in a carry on size.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '18
A few things.
Both bags are MASSIVE and will be hard to carry on an international flight due to size and weight. You want something more along the lines of a 30-35L, especially if you have a small daypack.
If you are going to be on foot a lot and on/off trains and the like in a place like India I’d look for something less “suitcase” shaped and more a pack that hugs your body, has better weight distribution and is more minimal. Both bags you mentioned are more soft square suitcase and less pack that rides well on your body. They are fine for urban travel but would be new rmy last choice for where you are going.
Take a look at Gossamar Gear Gorilla 40 or Kumo 36. More traditional packs but will be infinitely more versatile for you on your trip. The bonus about a pack like this is you can get the right size for your torso.
If you want something more “suitcasey” look at the Incase EO. It’s much more reasonably sized than either pack you mentioned but still gives you the features you seem to want of a suitcase. I own one of these and it’s my “big” bag when I travel. I have never had size issues with it as a carryon but you can still pack it too heavy. This bag is basically a better designed and sized MLC.
I had a 45L Patagonia MLC years ago and while it’s a lovely made bag and I’m a big fan of Patagonia anything... it’s a horrible bag in actuality due to its size, shape and lack of structure. You’d be better off with a $20 duffel from Walmart.