r/bangladesh Aug 05 '24

AskDesh/দেশ কে জিজ্ঞাসা Communal violence must be resisted

Hindu people are being attacked. Temples are being broken. The situation is alarming. It's against the spirit of a peaceful country. We should strongly condemn the attacks and avert from now.

465 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

28

u/ozzy555556 Aug 05 '24

Please protect our minorities! We are all Bangladeshi! We have the same rights.

11

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

People will protect them surely.

2

u/lifthor Aug 06 '24

Aren't they being targeted by the people themselves?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Dawndraco Aug 07 '24

Bruh, we all know both Jamaat & BNP are anti-hindu & anti-india so please stop with your bs!

70

u/Koyander Aug 05 '24

Bangladesh folks, save minority Hindus, they are like brothers and sisters, please don’t attack temples or attack people, this will only show your country in poor view, elect new government and show the quality, over here in India treat Muslims like anyone else and no time to waste ideas on communal violences, rest is up to you…

47

u/Open_Efficiency_6732 Aug 05 '24

Hope exists-

31

u/Open_Efficiency_6732 Aug 05 '24

Muslim volunteers defending a temple

5

u/SomratKhan1608 Aug 05 '24

A true Mumin (Believer) and Muslim (One who submitted to God)!

9

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

That's really encouraging. We'll try to do the same in the upcoming days.

21

u/Open_Efficiency_6732 Aug 05 '24

We will.here have another one--

5

u/__ExactFactor__ Aug 05 '24

Good job. Stand with our Hindu and other minority brothers. They are our people. We are their people. This nation, Bangladesh belongs to them and us equally. We are all free people. Free people protect each other when needed and respect each other.

Anyone who attacks Hindus in Bangladesh are not Bangladehis or human beings. They are scums. Even if those Hindus supported BAL. In a free nation, people can support any political party without fear.

I will personally donate money to Hindu families to rebuild. Fuck religious fanaticism even if they are from my own religion. We stand for all people's rights and freedom from the backward villages of Bangladesh to the most swankiest of palaces in France. Freedom for all.

3

u/GiantJupiter45 Indian 🇮🇳 Among us Aug 05 '24

ধন্যবাদ আমাদের হয়ে ওখানে অন্যায়ের বিরুদ্ধে লড়ার জন্য :)

1

u/Dapper_Layer3200 Aug 06 '24

Nice photoshoot , now post the picture where they are running from mob .

10

u/ozzy555556 Aug 05 '24

Hindus, Muslims, Christians, buddhists - we are all Bangladeshi and we all love our country. Please protect them and speak up

42

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[deleted]

47

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

It's pathetic. It would be a nightmare if the islamist parties get hold of the power.

30

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[deleted]

16

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

I'm agree with you that Jamat won't be in power. But unfortunately, Islamic cards are played by most of the political parties.

13

u/DBKolbalish Aug 05 '24

You don't know your countrymen yet. The majority would vote any party blindly that uses the Islam card.

1

u/Duckkooo Aug 05 '24

nah. most ppl r aware tht jamaat e islam isnt even following islam lol- just uses it for power and fame

-1

u/Oilfish01 Aug 05 '24

Never in the history of Pakistan a religious party has come to power by popular mandate. It was the military dictatorship of ZIA which made religious influence mainstream. Even recently concluded elections this year Jammat-e-Islami Pakistan didn’t win many seats as people think.

2

u/CrazyLich79 Aug 06 '24

I would add that people don't remember Zia fondly, nor was he seen as a "religious" dictator. His implementation of Islam was made with alterations to the fundamental rules laid down by the Quran, the Prophet (peace be upon him), and those followed by the companions. So this isn't a case of "Islam isn't popular" or "Islam is unjust", it's a case of local traditions and personal desires of the implementer altering it's fundamentals in an unjust manner. No party in Pakistan can come to power without at least calling itself Islamic at face-value. This is not to say that they are all sincere in this or even Islamic, but rather that what appeals to Muslims is Islam and those who adhere to it, at least to their knowledge. Additionally, have you considered that perhaps what is preventing an actual Islamic party from holding the mandate isn't the populaces distaste for Islam (as you seem to be insinuating falsely) but rather that the political, economic and military structure of the nation is built around the British colonial example? Is it in the interest of the rich and powerful who became so under a secular system which was used to massacre, oppress, suppress and eventually subdue the local religious communities (Muslim, Hindu, Sikh, or Buddhist) to allow for a party which wishes to remove it and fix it see empowered? The military dictatorships and government used KP and Balochistan as bases to radicalize the populace, teach them some altered version of Islam which turns su-cide into martyrdom, fabricated ahadith, and then when they couldn't control these elements to justify their power and elevated status, turned on them.

As for your statement of "Zia making religious influence mainstream", my brother, we are Muslims. We fought for independence so we could practice our religion freely instead of being sidelined and mocked for following it. The packaging in which Pakistan was sold to Muslims was a "nation for Muslims to practice Islam freely". The constitution was required to be based in Islam from the day we achieved independence. The army glorified itself on the basis of it's shuhada (martyrs). The government parties emphasize that they are Muslims and thank Allah for winning the mandate when elected. Your statement is utter rubbish. Islam was mainstream among us since we became Muslims and it will remain so.

7

u/zefiax Aug 05 '24

BNP is no different, they are allied with jamaat

1

u/gokjib Aug 05 '24

Awami league has the same intention as Jamat?

15

u/Refa01 Aug 05 '24

I also think Chatra Leauge is doing this, so they can create hatred By Indians toward Bengalis. They lost and will do anything to keep the country disable . Also it could be other political parties, both can be possible

8

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

It will be clear soon who are doing this. Miscreants are not people from other countries. They will be revealed by their neighbors, society.

3

u/Refa01 Aug 05 '24

I hope so, and these people should be punished. The students leaders should make a statement and were the students leaders invited to the talk with Army Chief?

2

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

The student leaders and civil society should raise their voices loudly against communal violence. I agree with you.

2

u/Refa01 Aug 05 '24

The army needs to sit with student leaders and broadcast that to whole country. Corruption, violence and unrest won’t stop until we form a proper democratic government.

32

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[deleted]

14

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

We should unite now anyway.

21

u/__ExactFactor__ Aug 05 '24

Hindus are being attacked by Indian goons, jamaat goons, and BAL+BNP goons. It's not the average people or student.

15

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

I agree. Most of the people don't support these attacks. Some miscreants are doing these. They should be addressed and averted soon.

4

u/ozzy555556 Aug 05 '24

Please speak up against this violence

4

u/__ExactFactor__ Aug 05 '24

Trust me. We are. I personally spoke with some relatives and ask them to check on the Hindu families nearby and to stay around their house overnight.

No citizen of Bangladesh should have to live in fear regardless of religion or non religion. We are a free people. We gave blood over and over and over for freedom. Not for just us but for all people. We love freedom for us and freedom for all. All minorities in Bangladesh do have and will have full 100% rights. Anyone who harms minorities are not of us and we will bring them to justice. If needed, we will revolt again.

5

u/Impressive_1020 Aug 05 '24

Irrespective of religion, all innocent civilians need protection, do your best in the worst time. Hindhu people deserve peace too.

7

u/Low-Cry-9808 Aug 05 '24 edited Aug 05 '24

I do not know actually what is escalating the attacks this time. As with all complex political situations, there maybe multiple factors at play here. But I saw news of villages after villages plundered and minorities being tortured, raped, killed etc after the 2001 election. We did not have social media back then but the leading newspapers reported it. I heard stories from my minority friends later on too. This is not an unusual pattern of behavior when the opposition party which is more right leaning is forecasted to come to power. Again not sure if that is the only factor this time. I am very heartened though by the call for help by young people and the community as a whole this time. We should remember how we feel when we visit or settle down abroad and are no longer the majority. When you are the majority since childhood and it is a largely homogenous community, it can become a habit to underestimate the plight of minorities.

6

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

I'm not sure why people are creating chaos. This is not freedom that we want. Freedom has to ensure security for all, not only for the majorities.

6

u/dhonshompotti Aug 05 '24

I don't understand why the army is not getting involved? They were supposed to provide the security of the people, properties and infrastructures, Right?

10

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

They seem to be very unprepared. The army chief looks embarrassed getting the control of the country suddenly.

11

u/0ni0n_peeler Aug 05 '24

Well they were all pawns of Hasina. Farmer murgi all of them, none of them merit based..... the only silver lining is they cant become gaddafi or putin.

2

u/NinjaMonkey22 Aug 05 '24

Army’s are generally to against external threats not maintaining peace. Often militaries stepping in to stop civil matters results in some sort of bloodshed. Hopefully any violence can quickly be stopped and the people of Bangladesh can work towards a new future.

3

u/Ok-Improvement820 Aug 06 '24

Fucking hell, we should not have helped you in 71. Ya'll are just as Hinduphobic, albeit your bigotry emerges in Bangla rather than urdu.

2

u/redarkane Aug 06 '24

We are being flooded by Indians in this subreddit who are actively spreading misinformation. Let the world know that it's the chattro league doing this. We have to combat this.

2

u/shadapal Aug 06 '24

Chattro league might do this. This is understandable. But we've to be sure. We've to resist the miscreants. We've to stand strong against them.

0

u/redarkane Aug 06 '24

They have the audacity to send Indian raw agents into our country and now flooding our subreddit too they always make everything about themselves.

2

u/PreferenceNo5011 Aug 06 '24

please share any tips on how to stay safe at the moment ? or how to defend during such attacks ?

2

u/shadapal Aug 06 '24

Most of the people don't want riot. The Muslims are creating awareness to protect the minorities. The situation will get better soon in my opinion.

1

u/PreferenceNo5011 Aug 07 '24

i hope for the same .

5

u/HEROauen Aug 05 '24

Unfortunately there is no hope for Hindus in Bangladesh. You allow extremist ideologies to exist and flourish for decades. There are not enough people to stand up for what is right. Once the Hindus are wiped out, you'll just find more people within Islam to do the same thing to. It's just a revolving door of targeting, and killing with no end.

1

u/Lezzzend Aug 05 '24

Awami League is doing such thing so Hindu oppression can be a reason for India to interfere. Students should now fight against Awami League leaders and their dogs.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/Embarrassed-Pianist7 Aug 05 '24

Everyone is just running on mob mentality now. No sense in saying anything about actual logic and concerns after witnessing the downfall of multiple countries after a “revolution”

6

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

The fear of downfall is not baseless. Sheikh Hasina has done enough damage for that.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Low-Cry-9808 Aug 05 '24

I think one reason is that a lot of them were born during latest BAL regime or were not old enough even if they were-to comprehend this common pattern present in BD politics regardless of parties. We needed societal reform first before a political one. Still hope some good reform will happen and it wont be exactly back to the same old.

1

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

I'm not sure how Hasina's development will help us. Foreign debt has gone many times higher. There was immense corruptions behind every mega project.

8

u/dhonshompotti Aug 05 '24

It is the job of the army to provide that security after the resignation. Why will the students provide that you awami clown? 🤡

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/bangladesh-ModTeam Aug 05 '24

This post was removed as it breaks reddiquette, which is a set of guidelines that all users of r/bangladesh follow in order to make the subreddit a civil discussion space.

This also includes discrimination or offensive language which is not tolerated here. This includes [racism](), misogyny, xenophobia, homophobia, and/or religious discrimination.

Be civil. Remember the human that you're interacting with.

While your post may have had substantive content, either right or wrong, we have had to remove this in order to be fair about enforcing the rules. Thank you for understanding.

Rule #1. Follow Reddiquette.

1

u/Honest-Computer69 Aug 05 '24

Yeah, and those retarded students should've planned on what the f will happen after BAL steps down. It seems like they have no plan and they're just letting BNP Jamat and military play the game of politics after f-ing our country up.

3

u/hakkahuya69 khati bangali 🇧🇩 খাঁটি বাঙালি Aug 05 '24

They are not even creating a party or talking about election . They have zero sense how democracy works. I just hope they learn fast and we don't get jamaat shibir or military gov.

9

u/shadapal Aug 05 '24

The defeat of dictator Hasina was necessary. The students have done well so far. The situation would get better soon I hope.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/bangladesh-ModTeam Aug 05 '24

This post was removed as it breaks reddiquette, which is a set of guidelines that all users of r/bangladesh follow in order to make the subreddit a civil discussion space.

This also includes discrimination or offensive language which is not tolerated here. This includes [racism](), misogyny, xenophobia, homophobia, and/or religious discrimination.

Be civil. Remember the human that you're interacting with.

While your post may have had substantive content, either right or wrong, we have had to remove this in order to be fair about enforcing the rules. Thank you for understanding.

Rule #1. Follow Reddiquette.

2

u/SomaticFrission Aug 05 '24

Indian army saved many in 1971 genocide. To turn to hinduphobia is a disgrace to the freedom fighters.

1

u/Constant-Guard3059 Aug 06 '24

Who is attacking the hindus? One part say bcl another says bnp-jamaat

0

u/Commercial_Place_668 Aug 05 '24

Many people are guarding temples now.3rd party is trying tarnish our holy protest. We built this Bangladesh together. We are united.

hinduaresafeinbangladesh

12

u/KetsuN0Ana Aug 06 '24

I hate this statement so much because it’s so untrue. Hindus are never safe in Bangladesh. I agree that Hindus have a lot of support (maybe that’s what the statement should be) but definitely not safe.

Every puja, in the back of our minds we wonder if there will be an attack. We are discriminated against in the workplace. Verbally abused due to the religion. Asked whether we have a second home in India. “Accidentally” fed beef. (There are many more and worse things but I’ve only listed the ones I have first hand experience with)

Next time this statement is said out loud, just think, Why does it even need to be said? Why is it not “Bangalis are safe in Bangladesh?” Why do we have to be referred to as the “Hindu minority” and not “Bangali” first as our identity? Why must we require protection in the country we were born in? It’s as if being Hindu made us a different class of citizen in our own country.

I respect all the people standing and supporting the Hindus, but Hindus are NOT safe in Bangladesh.

2

u/Tall_Instruction_871 Aug 06 '24

Islam is only united with Islam

0

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Bousine Aug 05 '24

I am sorry but it's BAL who is executing these attacks on the minorities. There's a deep plot for sure.