r/PublicFreakout Oct 01 '24

🌎 World Events Missile impacts in Israel

22.0k Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.8k

u/savois-faire Oct 01 '24

Ballistic missiles are harder to take down.

925

u/trailsman Oct 01 '24

The barrage of many missiles also makes it much more difficult to intercept.

491

u/simba4141 Oct 01 '24

Sort of DDOS...

647

u/2000gatekeeper Oct 01 '24

Distributed Denial of Survival 💀

82

u/Huge_Helicopter Oct 01 '24

I hate myself for laughing at that

6

u/Flyerone Oct 01 '24

Those damn Missile kiddies

2

u/trailsman Oct 01 '24

100%

That's the strategy now too with drone attacks.

2

u/fuzzydunloblaw Oct 01 '24

Iranian DOS hackers   

C:  

CD \ISRAEL  

DEL *.*

1

u/ferchoec Oct 01 '24

God damn you all, why do you make me laugh in this very worrisome moment.

2

u/GrandmaPoses Oct 01 '24

Why use few missiles when many missiles do trick?

1

u/Iminurcomputer Oct 02 '24

So if I shoot more missiles at my target I have a better chance of causing more destruction? Their military prowess is astounding. Where do they even come up with this shit?

6

u/ned23943 Oct 01 '24

That didn't look like a ballistic missile. A ballistic missile coming from Iran would have a near vertical descent to the target

111

u/BigBallsMcGirk Oct 01 '24

It had a ballistic trajectory. And it's a missile.

61

u/navi_brink Oct 01 '24

They’re obviously photon torpedoes from the U.S.S. Enterprise

9

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/j1ggy Oct 02 '24

Now they're just stuck in the pattern buffer.

3

u/MyOtherAvatar Oct 01 '24

More likely to be plasma torpedoes from a Romulan bird of prey.

1

u/navi_brink Oct 01 '24

Ugh, those Romulan scum

2

u/Babyyougotastew4422 Oct 01 '24

Ayotolla drinks earl grey while he plays backgammon

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24

When they went back in time and attacked MAGA, and set their phasers to Dumb.

Worst episode ever.

12

u/Jadccroad Oct 01 '24

I think you may be assuming that all ballistic missiles use the same attack arc despite having wildly variable ranges.

Ballistic does not mean it goes into space, and that's the only time you're going to end up with "nearly vertical" arcs. You always want the path of least action, or as close to it as you can get. For an atmospheric missile to have that steep an angle it would need to bleed off momentum to change from its approach angle, making it easier to hit with interceptors.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24 edited Oct 01 '24

Ballistic means an object has a propellant force applied to it, and it travels along a trajectory, and strikes something at the end of its trajectory.

“Internal ballistics” is the study of the propellant force and its behaviour at the beginning of the object’s trajectory;

“Transitional Ballistics” studies the behaviour of the object along its trajectory;

“Terminal Ballistics” studies the behaviour of the object at the end of its trajectory.

Samuel Colt, when the US Patent Office demanded that he describe what a “gun” is wrote, “A gun is a device for throwing balls.”

17

u/monsterdiggare Oct 01 '24

These are supersonic missiles, I think.

27

u/ExperimentalFailures Oct 01 '24

So are all ballistic missiles.

1

u/monsterdiggare Oct 01 '24

Oh... Didn't know that.

14

u/ExperimentalFailures Oct 01 '24

Supersonic just means above Mach 1. Quite slow for a missile. Ballistic misslies are even hypersonic after re-entry from space, meaning above Mach 5.

But judging for your many upvotes, a lot of people are very missinformed about technical details. Which is fine.

Ballistic misslies are kind of cool though. Launch a missile into space, and let gravity pull it back in order to re-enter at an insane speed so that it's really hard to shoot down.

5

u/monsterdiggare Oct 01 '24

Cool, I guess... Thanks for the info!

1

u/TheGov3rnor Oct 01 '24

Iranian state TV reported earlier that in today’s attack, the Iranian military used Fattah hypersonic missiles on Israel for the first time.

0

u/meatloaf_man Oct 01 '24

That's a jdam \s

-3

u/New_Sage_ForgeWorks Oct 01 '24

I think they are regular sonic tbh.

2

u/scorcherdarkly Oct 01 '24

Intercontinental ballistic missiles would have a near-vertical terminal trajectory. But ICBMs aren't the only kind of ballistic missiles.

There are five different "types" of ballistic missiles based on range: Close range, Short range, Medium range, Intermediate Range, and Intercontinental. Given the range between Iran and Israel, the missiles used today were likely Medium Range Shabab-3 or Khorramshahr missiles.

2

u/torero15 Oct 01 '24

Except that they are. Otherwise well done.

2

u/Corregidor Oct 01 '24

You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about lmao 🤣

2

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24

[deleted]

4

u/Careful_Farmer_2879 Oct 01 '24

No. Ballistic refers to the trajectory.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24

[deleted]

1

u/NousSommesSiamese Oct 01 '24

They should have asked ChatGPT how to do it /s

1

u/OtisPan Oct 02 '24

I'm wondering if the commenter meant that another way?

Here (Canada, CBC) on the news, they were reporting that everything was intercepted and nothing hit the ground.

0

u/fear_the_future Oct 01 '24

No they are not. In fact they are far far easier because they follow a ballistic trajectory... like the name says. A cruise missile can turn whenever it wants.

1

u/Vanq86 Oct 02 '24

They are harder to shoot down in large numbers though, as there is less time available to intercept them. If your SAM launcher only holds 6 missiles, and there's 7 ballistic missiles screaming toward you from the edge of space, you're screwed. With cruise missiles and good radar covers you may have time to reload your launchers and fire off another salvo of interceptors.

0

u/midnightbandit- Oct 01 '24

Which these aren't

0

u/Glittering_Guides Oct 01 '24

Why? Ballistic missiles trajectories are easy to calculate.