r/JewsOfConscience • u/nikiyaki • Oct 31 '24
r/JewsOfConscience • u/reddagger • Sep 27 '24
History American Jews Have Long Questioned Zionism
r/JewsOfConscience • u/lightiggy • Nov 01 '24
History Before 1967, many Western Jews who were sympathetic to Israel still kept it at arm's length. In 1950, American Jewish Committee President Jacob Blaustein met with Israeli Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion. While he was friendly towards Israel, Blaustein was adamant that it did not represent all Jews.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/MooreThird • Nov 20 '24
History Germany's first Genocide was NOT the Holocaust
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Realistic-Call7925 • Mar 26 '24
History Need Historical sources on the intrinsic Jewish white supremacist character of Zionism from early zionists from the time of the founding of Israel and before that time.
Im writing a History essay and I've chosen to argue that Zionism is intrinsically supremacist in nature and makes clear calls for the establishment of a Jewish homeland through the use of ethnic cleansing and displacement of Palestinians. Other sources that refer to mizrahi jews or arab jews as lesser or tainted, from an Ashkenazi Eurocentric perspective are also welcome. Right now, I'm just researching and would like to gather as many primary, and secondary sources as possible before I start writing.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Aurelian828 • Apr 30 '24
History Marek Edelman one of the leaders of the Jewish resistance that fought against nazi Germany supported the Palestinian cause and the Palestinian resistance!
r/JewsOfConscience • u/endingcolonialism • 8d ago
History "Taking Back the Narrative" is a self-proclaimed Zionist education initiative whose slogan is "There is no Israel without Jews, no Jews without Israel". What it has to say about Jews without Israel in Gaza over centuries is fascinating.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/xGentian_violet • Sep 04 '24
History 8 years ago, IDF Deputy Chief Likened 'Revolting Trends' in Israeli Society to pre-Holocaust Germany.
haaretz.comr/JewsOfConscience • u/sheldonalpha5 • Apr 19 '24
History Iran’s Jewish community in Esfahan: We ‘feel at home’
Because Isfahan is in the news for not exactly the right reasons.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/CJIsABusta • Nov 11 '24
History The Red Front was a group of Palestinian and "Israeli" Marxist-Leninists that attempted to join the PLO in 1972 and was arrested and imprisoned for treason by the zionist authorities the year later
They were released in a prisoner exchange in 1985.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Roy4Pris • Oct 01 '24
History '... the Jewish nice...' A gently amusing transcription error in the Times Machine
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Roy4Pris • 22d ago
History Great little video
Sorry if TikTok is not allowed here. Not my usual platform, but I stumbled across this guy, a professor of government at Austin community college with some pithy comments about Israel.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Artistic-Vanilla-899 • Jul 12 '24
History The Dozen D's of Israeli Zionist State Propoganda -Hasbara
I came across this quick great summary exploring Israel's propaganda strategies. If Israeli Zionist leaders cannot control the flow of information and dissemination of knowledge, how is it defenisble?. If opponents of Zionism and its victims have a voice and a platform, how can can Hasbara be effective ?
The historical narrative is revised, reversed. The perpetrators claim victimhoom. We must know only the Israeli story and its sense of self-righteousness. Palestinians must not be known to have existed and owned the land since tome began. Zionists are the Romans chanting " Carthago delenda est" - Carthage must be destroyed. Except Zionism wants to say....wait there is no Palestine or a Palestinian people.
It's ironic and totally lost to its intended audience when the Yad Vashem Holocaust Memorial in Israel exhibits the use of Nazi state propaganda as a tool for making the Holocaust, while the Israeli state uses mass propaganda, including the Yad Vashem as a means of propaganda, justifying Zionism while subjugating of millions of people to build the Israeli state and faces charges of genocide.
This article tries to argue Hasbara is becoming effective, but could the state of Israel become more cruel, totalitarian and fascist, and switch from Hasbara as a means of communication in the public sphere to just brute force, using repression and violence to eliminate dissent?
Hasbara is way more stupid now and doesn't even try as hard to persuade. Is Israeli state diplomacy becoming less of an explanation and more in the form of dropping American bombs, killing indiscriminately, targeting civilian aid workers, journalists, doctors, artists, teachers, and bribing or lobbying for influence in other countries? Netanyahu and this government boast their ability to kill and scorch the earth.
I think while Hasbara is failing, homicidal mania is rising. It's not about convincing or persuading through explanation. It's through state terror.
Will the failure of Hasbara really make Zionists suddenly rational?
See Finklestein's clip on YouTube: Israel has gone "certifiabmy insane."
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Specialist-Gur • Aug 14 '24
History Seeking recommendations!
Any really good history podcasts or history channels to listen to? I want to deep dive into history of empires, historical atrocities, basically history in general… particularly if it’s not commonly talked about history. I really want to deep dive but I’m not the best reader, so listening would be ideal.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Artistic-Vanilla-899 • Aug 19 '24
History Dahiya Doctrine:
The Dahiya Doctrine was crafted in 2008. It tells the IDF to use disproportionate lethal force against civilian populations. It is a partnership between Israel and America.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/thatretroartist • Aug 24 '24
History A fascinating short essay on Zionist antisemitism from the 1946 YIVO Annual of Jewish Social Science. Adeptly describes the antisemitism baked into Zionism, as well as predicting the supremacist ideology that would become core to the founding of Israel two years later
r/JewsOfConscience • u/lightiggy • Apr 18 '24
History In 1917, the British cabinet had one Jewish member: Edwin Montagu. Montagu was also one of the strongest British opponents of the Balfour Declaration issued that year. He viewed Zionism as a "mischievous political creed" and the declaration itself as highly and inherently antisemitic.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Working-Lifeguard587 • Jul 27 '24
History A Jewish socialist critique of Zionism, from 1906
r/JewsOfConscience • u/isawasin • Feb 23 '24
History The Forgotten History of the Jewish, Anti-Zionist Left
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Roy4Pris • Mar 27 '24
History In 1939, Palestine's largest crop was Jaffa oranges, with 30,000 hectares under cultivation.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Two_Word_Sentence • Jul 03 '24
History "What is wrong with the Israelis?"
This article deeply explores Zionism, and explains the ultra violence and perverse behaviors of Israeli soldiers, the moral contradictios and inversions, and how Zionism requires those behaviors in order to be sustained.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Roy4Pris • Jul 11 '24
History Love the footage, and the calm, dispassionate narration
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Artistic-Vanilla-899 • Sep 13 '24
History Today in history. 13 September 1993: Oslo Accords I
Are Palestinian liberation and Zionism mutually exclusive in the region known as Palestine or Israel?
Did Zionists, even Rabin himself, fully and consciously intend to grant Palestinians sovereignty on lands they've occupied?
I think Israelis in charge in general wanted to make Arafat and the PLO pacify itself, not to accept the State of Palestine. Arafat and PLO rejected that deal in 2000 to grant it a a state, because that state would be a tool for America and Israel. Arafat was asked to sell the hopes of Palestinian self-determination to the occupiers without addressing the roots of Palestinian justified grievances, namely the Nakba, the right of return, the indignation, giving up the right of a Palestinian state to have a defense force.
Is that a valid interpretation?
Would acceptance of this 2SS basically have legalized Israeli oppression of Palestinians in occupied territories, and over time, in the name of national security, annexation would be the de facto situation, as a weak Palestinian state gradually withered away.
Was there a reason to think Israeli forces would ever entirely lay hands off Palestinian sovereign territories? That 2ss would have made the Palestinian liberation movement as impotent as the PA in the West Bank today.
Israel seems to have this historical strategy of blaming Palestinians for rejecting terms set in favor of Zionists and that are offensive to many Palestinians. The failure of the Oslo Accords was believing being granted a weak state would have satisfied and pacified Palestinians and that Zionists were willing to accept sovereign Palestinians in land they think the god they don't believe in gave only to them.
Here is an article summarizing a view of Oslo from a Pro-Palestine perspective. https://imeu.org/article/explainer-the-oslo-accords
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Artistic-Vanilla-899 • Mar 20 '24
History When Israel's Sephardic Black Panthers Used Passover To Decry Jewish 'Racism'
This is fascinating. Take a look at this quote..
"It is a crime to destroy the culture of an entire people,” the Haggadah’s authors wrote. “You took our culture that we brought with us from the Diaspora and promised a different one in its place. But you forsook us and discriminated against our communities by rendering us without culture and without faith, leaving us suspended in a cultureless vacuum.”
Is it true that many non-Ashkenazi who settled in Israel weren't really on board with Zionism at the beginning of Israel, and Zionism was a catalyst that drove the mass migration of Sephardic and Mizrahi from their homelands to Israel after (I don't want to say anything controversial and I haven't really studied this topic) their expulsion?
So even maybe half the population of Israeli Jews after Israel's Independence were reluctant Israelis and didn't receive the best treatment from the European elites running the show.
Has the Zionist narrative kind of retold a different story about much of the diaspora's identity and history than it really was? For example, the Jewish presence in Iraq went back over 2000 years. That was a homeland and a culture outside of the Land of Israel,, until Zionism overturned history and they fled to Israel, where like the article says, it was a struggle.
Zionism seems to have not only disrupted Palestinian culture and history, but also for much if its own people. Is that fair to say?
Zionism....a "cultureless vacuum"
r/JewsOfConscience • u/e_shamis • Apr 15 '24
History What do you guys think of operation Yachin: zionists forced the expulsion of “arab” Jews 59 Israel
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Yachin
Arab Jews to Israel ** sorry for typo.
There’s a few of these around the Arab word including this:
Three Worlds: Memoirs of an Arab-Jew, Shlaim unveils "undeniable proof of Zionist involvement in the terrorist attacks" which prompted a mass exodus of Jews from Iraq between 1950 and 1951.